GOP Senators Revolt Against Thune After Election Losses
Intra-Party Split Detected
At least seven Republican senators (Johnson, Scott, Lee, Budd, Kennedy, McCormick, Banks) are publicly pushing to delay Thune's leadership re-election and demanding a strategy review after midterm losses, while the broader conference appears set to re-elect Thune and other incumbent leaders without a serious challenger.
Left says
- •The rushed timeline for leadership elections, held just a week after sweeping GOP losses in the House and Senate, suggests party leaders are more interested in protecting their own positions than conducting an honest post-mortem on why voters rejected Republicans.
- •Thune's push to lock in his leadership before any substantive debate on strategy mirrors a broader pattern of entrenched incumbency that insulates party leaders from accountability even after major electoral failures.
- •The internal chaos and lack of a credible primary challenger to Thune highlights a GOP conference that is fractured and directionless but still unwilling to make real changes.
Right says
- •Senators like Ron Johnson, Rick Scott, Mike Lee, Ted Budd and John Kennedy believe the conference owes it to voters and grassroots Republicans to have a genuine strategic discussion before rewarding leadership that presided over devastating midterm losses.
- •Holding a leadership vote one week after losing both chambers, without a broader conference discussion on what went wrong, looks like leadership trying to avoid scrutiny rather than confront failure honestly.
- •Unfinished priorities like the SAVE America Act and concerns that Thune may be working against conservative figures like Tim Burchett reflect deeper frustration that leadership has drifted from the values that energize the base.
- •Trump's own criticism of the Senate for failing to pass key legislation reinforces the view among conservatives that current leadership has not delivered results commensurate with the political capital it was given.
Common Take
High Consensus- Republicans lost control of both the House and Senate in the recent midterm elections.
- A leadership election was scheduled for the Tuesday following the midterm losses.
- Multiple senators, including Ron Johnson, Rick Scott, Mike Lee, Ted Budd and John Kennedy, formally requested a delay to allow for a broader conference discussion.
- No senator has emerged to formally challenge Thune for the top leadership position.
The Arguments
Left argues
Rushing leadership elections just one week after devastating midterm losses suggests Thune and his allies are prioritizing self-preservation over an honest reckoning with why voters rejected the party.
Right counters
Conference rules and timelines exist independent of any single election cycle, and delaying leadership votes indefinitely could create a power vacuum that leaves the party even less equipped to respond to Democratic control of Congress.
Right argues
Senators like Ron Johnson and Rick Scott are right to demand a substantive strategic discussion before re-anointing leadership, since skipping that debate signals the conference would rather protect incumbents than learn from failure.
Left counters
If these same senators had no credible alternative candidate to Thune, their complaints function more as political theater than a genuine push for change, since symbolic objections without actionable alternatives rarely produce real accountability.
Right argues
Unfinished priorities like the SAVE America Act and reports that Thune may be undermining conservative figures like Tim Burchett suggest leadership has drifted from the base's priorities even while asking for continued trust.
Left counters
Internal GOP infighting over personalities and unfinished legislation reflects a party more consumed with factional score-settling than with addressing the substantive policy failures that actually cost them the majority.
Left argues
The lack of any credible primary challenger to Thune, despite widespread grumbling, exposes a GOP conference that is fractured and dissatisfied but structurally incapable of producing real change or accountability.
Right counters
The absence of a challenger doesn't mean senators lack leverage — public pressure campaigns, delay petitions, and threatened walkouts are legitimate tools for forcing leadership to address strategic failures without needing to immediately depose them.
Right argues
Trump's own public criticism of the Senate's failure to pass major legislation validates grassroots conservative frustration that current leadership has not delivered results proportional to the power it was given.
Left counters
Invoking Trump's criticism as justification is selective, since Trump's complaints about Senate inaction often reflect his own shifting priorities and demands rather than a coherent, consistent standard Thune's leadership failed to meet.
Challenge Questions
These questions target genuine internal contradictions — meant to provoke honest reflection.
Right asks Left
“If the rushed election timeline is evidence of leadership avoiding accountability, what specific alternative process would have produced a meaningfully different outcome given that no senator was willing to challenge Thune?”
Left asks Right
“If senators like Johnson and Scott believe the conference needs a genuine strategic reckoning, why did none of them step forward as an alternative candidate rather than merely delaying the vote?”
Outlier Report
Left Fringe
Figures like Mehdi Hasan or progressive commentators on social media who frame this as proof the entire GOP is irredeemably corrupt and incapable of reform represent maybe 15-20% of the left, as most Democratic-leaning observers view this more passively as factional infighting rather than a moral indictment.
Right Fringe
Ron Johnson and allies like Mike Lee pushing for a walkout and public confrontation represent a vocal but minority faction (perhaps 20-25% of the right), while most rank-and-file Republicans and figures like Trump himself express frustration with outcomes but aren't necessarily demanding Thune's removal or a full revolt.
Sources (6)
A handful of Republican senators have at least attempted to slow the coronation train for failed Senate Majority Leader John Thune, R-S.D. The South Dakota Republican announced shortly after the GOP got its brains beat out in Tuesday's midterm that since he was so successful in losing the majority, he would very much like to lead Senate Republicans as a significantly diminished minority. Thune and his swamp buddies moved quickly to try to secure their leadership positions, calling conference elections for Tuesday — exactly one week after the party lost control of the House and Senate in the blue trouncing...
<p>Seven Republican senators now are calling for their <a href="https://www.axios.com/2026/11/09/mccormick-delay-senate-gop-leadership-election-thune" target="_blank">leadership elections to be delayed</a> — with one even promising to walk out rather than vote Tuesday.</p><p><strong>Why it matters: </strong>Senate Majority Leader <a href="https://www.axios.com/2026/09/23/john-thune-senate-republican-leader-trump" target="_blank">John Thune</a> (R-S.D.) is still expected to be reelected to lead the Senate GOP tomorrow. But the growing push to delay is a sign of troubles ahead.</p><hr /><p><strong>Driving the news: </strong>Sens. Ron Johnson (R-Wisc.), Rick Scott (R-Fla.), Mike Lee (R-Utah), Ted Budd (R-N.C.) and John Kennedy (R-La.) all signed a letter demanding that the leadership elections be delayed to allow for more discussion about what went wrong for the party last week. </p><ul><li>Sens. Dave McCormick (R-Pa.) and Jim Banks (R-Ind.) backed them up in statements posted on X. </li><li>Johnson <a href="https://x.com/disivak/status/2119891315345543359?s=46" target="_blank">threatened</a> to skip the vote if the delay doesn't happen.</li></ul><p><strong>Between the lines:</strong> The decision technically falls to conference chair Tom Cotton (R-Ark.) — though it's usually made with leadership buy-in.</p><ul><li>The election is expected to be held as planned Tuesday morning unless a senator motions to delay and it passes with a majority — which seems unlikely with the number of public supporters, according to a source familiar with the planning discussions.</li><li>Despite the arguments that Thune should not get to lock in his leadership so quickly, no one has thrown their hat in the ring to challenge him. </li></ul><p><strong>The bottom line:</strong> At this point, none of the leadership elections are competitive. </p><ul><li>Senate Majority Whip John Barrasso (R-Wyo.), Conference Chair Tom Cotton (R-Ark.) Policy Committee Chair Shelley Moore Capito (R-W.Va.) and Conference Vice Chair James Lankford (R-Okla.) are expected to keep their spots as Nos. 2, 3, 4 and 5 atop the conference. Moreno is the sole candidate for NRSC chair. </li></ul>
On this full episode of LARRY, we dive into the Republican revolt building around John Thune after the GOP’s stunning Senate loss, Thune praising his own record while moving ahead with a leadership election, Donald Trump blasting the Senate for getting nothing passed, Ron Johnson calling the rushed vote “political malpractice,” the growing list of Republican senators demanding a delay before tomorrow’s secret ballot, Jim Banks insisting the conference confront where it fell short, the unfinished fight to pass the SAVE America Act, Tim Burchett warning Republicans lose when they compromise their values, the report that Thune is working to keep Burchett out of the Senate, and MUCH, much more!
Sen. Ron Johnson of Wisconsin joined the “Tony Kinnett Cast” Monday night in an exclusive interview to discuss the upcoming Senate Republican leadership election scheduled for Tuesday. Johnson is currently petitioning to delay the leadership election in order to have a conference-wide meeting to discuss strategy. “After this devastating loss, after we realize that our...
Sen. Ron Johnson (R-Wis.) pledged to walk out of the room if his Republican colleagues proceed with leadership elections on Tuesday, after calling a conference to discuss the party’s direction following significant losses for the GOP in the midterm elections. “If you hold the election, I’ll leave the room,” he told the Washington Examiner in…
President Trump appointed Stephen Miller as white house chief of staff following the midterm elections, a move critics argue ignores voter rejection of his administration's immigration policies.