Topics /
Jack Smith
9 stories on Jack Smith. For each one: what the left says, what the right says, and what both agree on. RSS feed
- Jack Smith Faces GOP Senators Who Call His Trump Probes Abuse of Power
Sep 30, 2026
Left: Smith stands by his decisions as special counsel, maintaining he brought charges based solely on evidence of Trump's own actions and not political motivation.
Right: Committee Chairman Chuck Grassley titled the hearing to reflect concerns about 'Jack Smith's Abuse of Authority and the Targeting of Republicans,' arguing Smith misused his investigative powers for political ends.
- GOP Lawmakers Sue Jack Smith Over 'Arctic Frost' Phone Records
Oct 2, 2026
Left: These lawsuits and bar complaints are part of a coordinated political campaign to delegitimize a lawful investigation into efforts to overturn the 2020 election, timed to Smith's Senate testimony.
Right: Smith obtained nondisclosure orders on subpoenas for lawmakers' phone records without telling the court the records belonged to sitting members of Congress, preventing them from challenging the subpoenas in time.
- Schmitt's Basketball Mix-Up Undercuts Jack Smith Grilling
Oct 1, 2026
Left: The mix-up illustrates a broader pattern of Republican senators pursuing unsubstantiated conspiracy theories about coordination between Jack Smith and Fulton County DA Fani Willis without factual grounding.
Right: Sen. Eric Schmitt defended himself by saying his job is simply to ask questions, framing the mix-up as a minor factual error rather than evidence of bad faith.
- Jack Smith's Trump Probe Collected Data on 639,000 GOP Donors
Oct 15, 2026
Left: Special counsel investigations routinely require broad subpoenas to financial and donor records to trace money flows and coordination in complex conspiracy cases.
Right: Collecting personal data on 639,000 everyday Republican donors and voters, including small-dollar contributors with donations as low as $1, far exceeds what was needed to investigate a narrow set of alleged crimes.
- Jordan Refers Jack Smith for Prosecution; Smith Says It's 'Weaponization'
Jul 24, 2026
Left: Smith testified truthfully by answering the specific questions asked, and the referral hinges on his failure to volunteer additional unrequested information rather than any actual falsehood, which even Jordan's letter concedes.
Right: Newly released documents show Smith's team accessed the content of text messages from 44 members of Congress, including both parties, raising serious constitutional concerns about privacy and the Speech or Debate Clause.
- Jack Smith Grilled Over Seizing Trump Donors' Bank Records
Sep 30, 2026
Left: Special counsel investigations routinely use subpoenas to obtain financial records when tracing funding sources tied to alleged fake elector schemes and efforts to overturn a certified election.
Right: Ordinary Americans who donated as little as $5 or $10 to Trump had their home addresses, bank account and routing numbers, and signatures swept up by federal subpoenas with no clear connection to the investigation's stated scope.
- Schmitt's 'Gotcha' on Jack Smith Backfires Over Basketball Mix-Up
Oct 3, 2026
Left: Schmitt's confrontation with Jack Smith was a staged 'gotcha' moment built on sloppy conspiracy theorizing rather than actual evidence, mistaking an Iowa Hawkeyes women's basketball game for an Atlanta Hawks NBA game.
Right: Schmitt's underlying concern was scrutinizing potential connections between officials who pursued legal action against Trump, a legitimate oversight function of the Senate Judiciary Committee.
- Jack Smith Subpoenaed 4,782 Small-Dollar Checks From Trump Donors
Sep 30, 2026
Left: Subpoenas for financial records are a routine investigative tool used to trace potential campaign finance violations, fraud, or other crimes, and the scope was reportedly tied to a specific investigative timeframe of September 2019 to August 2023.
Right: Ordinary Americans who donated as little as $5 to $10 to a political campaign had their bank account numbers, routing numbers, signatures, and home addresses exposed to federal investigators without any apparent connection to a crime.
- Jack Smith's Team Collected Data on 639,000 GOP Donors, Voters
Oct 15, 2026
Left: The investigation concerned an alleged conspiracy to overturn a presidential election, a matter of extraordinary national importance that justified a broad evidentiary sweep.
Right: Collecting detailed personal data on over 639,000 everyday Republican voters and donors, most of whom gave small-dollar amounts, far exceeds what was needed to investigate the narrow scope of January 6-related conduct.