Topics /
Title IX
18 stories on Title IX. For each one: what the left says, what the right says, and what both agree on. RSS feed
- Cornell Gang Rape Case Reopened: Credible Accusation or Campus Hoax?
Sep 29, 2026
Left: The Snapchat messages soliciting other men to join in describe a culture of entitlement to women's bodies that deserves scrutiny regardless of how the criminal case unfolds.
Right: The district attorney's own account that the accuser initially described the encounter to police as voluntary, conscious, and consensual, only for the story to change substantially in a civil lawsuit filed nearly two years later, raises serious questions about the reliability of the new allegations.
- Cornell Rape Case: Was It Assault or Regret?
Oct 16, 2026
Left: Cornell's own investigation already found the assault occurred, resulting in two expulsions, yet the university failed to follow up on the woman's welfare or the outcome of the disciplinary process for years, revealing institutional indifference.
Right: The woman reportedly described the encounter as consensual in the days immediately following it, only changing her account roughly two weeks later, raising legitimate questions about what actually occurred that night.
- Cornell Gang Rape Lawsuit Sparks Clash Over Consent and Accountability
Oct 2, 2026
Left: Sexual violence follows predictable patterns in which men exploit intoxication and social hierarchy to assault women who are vulnerable, and institutions routinely fail to treat these patterns seriously.
Right: Rape allegations deserve serious scrutiny rather than automatic belief, and questioning inconsistencies in a case should not be treated as siding against victims generally.
- Cornell Bans Frat Parties — Critics Call It a 'Half Measure'
Oct 14, 2026
Left: The university's response came only after weeks of public pressure and student protests, raising questions about whether Cornell would have acted at all absent the lawsuit and national outrage.
Right: The accused men have denied the allegations, and none of the seven fraternity members has been criminally charged, meaning the university is imposing sweeping punishments on an entire social system before any legal determination of wrongdoing.
- Cornell Gang Rape Case: Bias Claims, Elite Ties, and University Failures Collide
Oct 17, 2026
Left: The case exposes a systemic pattern where institutions and law enforcement dismiss sexual assault allegations without genuine investigation, letting accused students avoid real accountability.
Right: Letitia James's public social media post expressing solidarity with Jane Doe before her appointment raises legitimate questions about whether she can lead an impartial investigation.
- Cornell 'Gang Rape' Case: Believed Victim or Media Hoax?
Oct 1, 2026
Left: A student's detailed lawsuit alleges she was drugged with ketamine and gang-raped over several hours, and survivors are too often re-traumatized by institutional and public skepticism.
Right: Newly surfaced text messages and the district attorney's own statement indicate the accuser described the encounters as 'voluntary, conscious, and consensual' when she first spoke to police in 2024.
- Cornell Faces No-Confidence Vote Over Handling of Gang Rape Case
Oct 16, 2026
Left: Jane Doe's case exposes a systemic pattern where universities and local prosecutors fail survivors by treating allegations with inadequate investigation and institutional self-protection rather than accountability.
Right: The case highlights real institutional failures in Cornell's investigation and the local prosecutor's office, which admitted it never independently investigated before declining to bring charges, raising legitimate due process and competence concerns for all parties involved.
- WNBA Star Sophie Cunningham Sparks Firestorm Over Trans Athletes in Women's Sports
Jul 25, 2026
Left: Framing transgender participation in women's sports as a fringe or radical issue overlooks the lived experiences and rights of transgender athletes, who make up a tiny fraction of competitors.
Right: Protecting the integrity and safety of women's sports categories is a matter of basic fairness rooted in biological differences, not animus toward transgender people.
- Trump Administration Terminates Civil Rights Protections for Transgender Students
Apr 7, 2026
Left: The termination removes federal oversight that ensured transgender students could access facilities and participate in activities consistent with their gender identity
Right: The previous agreements exceeded federal authority by interpreting Title IX beyond its original scope of biological sex discrimination
- Did Cornell and Prosecutors Bury a Rape Report?
Oct 2, 2026
Left: The newly surfaced transcript shows Jane Doe told police just weeks after the incident that she was 'completely and totally incapacitated' and could say 'with 100% confidence' she was raped, undercutting claims that her account only hardened later in a civil lawsuit.
Right: The Tompkins County district attorney maintains that the woman's original statement to police did not include allegations of being drugged, incapacitated beyond consent, or forced into sex, and that this is why charges weren't filed at the time.
- Trump Ends Biden's LGBTQ Title IX Protections, Restores 2020 Rules
Sep 30, 2026
Left: This rollback removes explicit federal recognition that discrimination based on sexual orientation and gender identity constitutes sex discrimination under Title IX, leaving LGBTQ students without clear federal protection from harassment and mistreatment at school.
Right: Restoring the 2020 rule aligns federal policy with recent court rulings and the Supreme Court's decision that Title IX's reference to sex means biological sex, not gender identity or sexual orientation.
- WNBA Star Sophie Cunningham Sparks Firestorm Over Trans Athletes in Women's Sports
Jul 26, 2026
Left: Framing the debate around 'biological men' erases the identities of transgender women, who advocates say are women, not men, and this language itself is seen as dehumanizing.
Right: Protecting fairness and safety for female athletes, especially minors, is treated as basic common sense rather than a political statement or an attack on transgender people.
- WNBA Star Sophie Cunningham Says Trans Athletes Don't Belong in Women's Sports
Jul 23, 2026
Left: Transgender inclusion in sports is framed as a human rights issue, and advocates argue that singling out trans athletes as threats to women's sports stigmatizes an already vulnerable population.
Right: Protecting fairness in women's sports means ensuring biological males, regardless of gender identity, don't compete against or share locker rooms with women and girls.
- Education Department Investigates Women's College for Admitting Trans Women
May 6, 2026
Left: The investigation represents the latest effort by the Trump administration to roll back transgender rights and protections established in recent years
Right: Smith College violates Title IX by allowing biological males to take admission spots specifically designated for women at a historically all-female institution
- Cornell Rape Case Reopens Fight Over Title IX Rules
Oct 2, 2026
Left: The Cornell case shows why robust Title IX enforcement matters, since a woman who told police she was certain she'd been raped still saw no criminal charges filed for nearly two years.
Right: The decision not to pursue criminal charges rested with the local district attorney based on the specifics of the woman's initial police statement, not on federal Title IX regulations.
- Wrestler Sues Over Alleged Assault by Trans Opponent Mid-Match
Aug 24, 2026
Left: Coverage of the WNBA and transgender athlete controversies often reflects broader cultural anxieties about race and gender rather than genuine concern for the league itself, with figures like Caitlin Clark and Sophie Cunningham elevated as symbols in a culture war rather than for their athletic achievements alone.
Right: Parents have a fundamental right to know in advance if their daughter may be matched against a biological male in a contact sport, and schools that withhold this information deny families the ability to protect their children.
- Should Trans Women Be Eligible to Play in the WNBA?
Aug 17, 2026
Left: Enes Kanter Freedom and Royce White's WNBA bids are widely seen even among trans-inclusive commentators as bad-faith trolling designed to embarrass the league rather than sincere attempts to compete, and their sincerity shouldn't be the test used to justify broader restrictions on trans athletes.
Right: Basic reproductive biology assigns humans to two sexes at conception, and male puberty confers durable physical advantages in size, strength, and speed that don't disappear with a change in gender identity or self-identification.
- Cornell Rape Case: Consensual Texts or Coerced Assault?
Oct 1, 2026
Left: Trauma responses vary widely, and victims often minimize, laugh, or maintain contact with assailants as coping mechanisms rather than evidence of consent.
Right: Contemporaneous texts in which she said the encounter was consensual and that she wanted to see the men again are hard to reconcile with a gang-rape allegation made two years later.