Topics /
Supreme Court
143 stories on Supreme Court. For each one: what the left says, what the right says, and what both agree on. RSS feed
- Supreme Court Lets Trump Push Mail-Voting Limits Before Midterms
Aug 26, 2026
Left: The ruling lets Trump proceed with an order that a federal appeals court warned could impose 'unprecedented levels of involvement by federal officials' in state-run elections, risking voter confusion and disenfranchisement just weeks before ballots go out.
Right: The ruling is a validation of commonsense election-integrity measures designed to ensure only eligible citizens cast ballots, addressing long-standing concerns about verification in mail voting.
- Virginia Supreme Court Strikes Down Democrat Redistricting After $70M Campaign
May 8, 2026
Left: The court's 4-3 decision overturns the will of over 3 million Virginia voters who democratically approved the redistricting referendum in April
Right: The Virginia Supreme Court correctly ruled that Democrats violated the state constitution's procedural requirements for constitutional amendments
- Supreme Court Guts Voting Rights Act in Racial Gerrymandering Ruling
Apr 29, 2026
Left: The decision effectively kills the last remaining powerful provision of the Voting Rights Act, rendering a landmark civil rights law 'all but a dead letter' after decades of Supreme Court erosion
Right: The Court correctly ruled that using race as the primary factor in drawing districts violates the Equal Protection Clause and creates unconstitutional racial gerrymandering
- SCOTUS Lets Trump Use Social Security Data to Purge Voters
Sep 26, 2026
Left: The SAVE database has a documented history of falsely flagging naturalized and native-born citizens as noncitizens, meaning eligible voters could be wrongly purged or forced to prove their citizenship weeks before an election.
Right: Federal law obligates DHS to respond to state and local requests verifying voter citizenship, and the ruling simply lets the government use the tool it considers best suited for that legitimate purpose.
- Court-Packing Vote Fails as Only One Democrat Breaks Ranks
Sep 3, 2026
Left: The amendment was a Republican-orchestrated messaging vote timed before the midterms to force Democrats into an unfavorable political position rather than a genuine legislative effort.
Right: The near-unanimous Democratic rejection confirms suspicions that the party is keeping court-packing on the table as a future option once they regain power.
- SCOTUS Lets Trump Use Social Security Data to Vet Voters
Sep 25, 2026
Left: The SAVE database has a documented history of false positives, meaning eligible citizens risk being wrongly flagged as noncitizens and purged from voter rolls.
Right: Federal law under the Illegal Immigration Reform and Immigrant Responsibility Act obligates DHS to share citizenship verification information with state and local election officials upon request.
- Supreme Court Lets Trump Restrict Mail Voting Weeks Before Midterms
Aug 25, 2026
Left: The ruling doesn't address whether Trump's order is actually constitutional, only whether states sued too soon, leaving voters vulnerable in the meantime with no clear path to challenge harm until it's already happening.
Right: The executive order is a lawful effort to verify citizenship and secure federal elections, and the states suing had not shown any concrete harm from an internal directive that doesn't dictate how they run their own elections.
- Court Blocks Trump's White House Ballroom; He Vows Supreme Court Fight
Aug 9, 2026
Left: The D.C. Circuit's 2-1 ruling affirms that the president cannot unilaterally demolish part of the White House and construct a $400 million complex without congressional authorization, reinforcing constitutional checks on executive power.
Right: Trump argues that as an elected president, he has inherent authority to renovate, secure, and improve the White House without needing permission from Congress, as past presidents have done for over two centuries.
- Trump Defies Supreme Court, Signs New Birthright Citizenship Orders
Aug 7, 2026
Left: The new orders are a workaround designed to achieve piecemeal what the Supreme Court already rejected wholesale, raising questions about whether the administration is respecting the separation of powers.
Right: The administration argues the Supreme Court's ruling in Trump v. Barbara left room for historical exceptions, and these orders are carefully tailored to fit within categories the Court itself recognized, like diplomats, occupying forces, and fraud.
- Supreme Court Preserves Mail-Order Abortion Pills Despite Conservative Dissents
May 15, 2026
Left: The decision protects essential healthcare access for women, ensuring they can continue receiving safe, FDA-approved medication through established telehealth and mail delivery systems
Right: The ruling undermines the Dobbs decision by allowing federal policy to circumvent individual states' democratically enacted abortion laws and sovereignty
- Supreme Court Blocks Trump-Backed Missouri GOP Map for Third Time
Sep 26, 2026
Left: The ruling ensures that more than a million Missouri voters shifted between districts under the 2025 map will vote using the same lines they've used since 2022, preserving stability and predictability for voters who signed petitions to challenge the gerrymander.
Right: Republicans argue voters are left with inconsistent rules, since candidates and districts used in the August primary now differ from what will appear on the November ballot, undermining electoral certainty and voter trust.
- Supreme Court Rules 8-1 Against Colorado's Conversion Therapy Ban
Apr 1, 2026
Left: The decision undermines protections for LGBTQ+ youth, who studies show are more than twice as likely to attempt suicide after experiencing conversion therapy
Right: The decision protects fundamental First Amendment rights against government-imposed orthodoxy in speech and thought
- Trump Admin's Third SCOTUS Bid to Enforce Mail Ballot Rules Before Midterms
Sep 6, 2026
Left: A federal judge twice found the rule likely unconstitutional, ruling it intrudes on both Congress's Elections Clause powers and states' traditional authority over elections, which have historically been run at the state and local level.
Right: The administration frames the USPS rule as a modest, lawful exercise of the Postal Service's own rulemaking authority over mail handling, not a federal takeover of state election administration.
- Supreme Court Redistricting Ruling Sparks Nationwide Gerrymandering War
May 2, 2026
Left: The Supreme Court's weakening of the Voting Rights Act removes crucial protections that prevented racial discrimination in redistricting and threatens minority representation in Congress
Right: The Supreme Court correctly ruled that the Voting Rights Act protects voting access but does not require race-based district drawing that amounts to unconstitutional racial gerrymandering
- Supreme Court Blocks Trump's Mail-Ballot Rules 7-2
Sep 15, 2026
Left: Elections are constitutionally and historically managed by states, and this ruling stops an attempt by the federal government to insert itself into how mail ballots are processed and delivered.
Right: The administration argued the barcode and voter-list requirements were modest, reasonable safeguards well within USPS's broad statutory authority to regulate the mail, not an unconstitutional federal takeover of elections.
- Trump imposes new tariffs on 60+ countries, citing forced labor claims
Jul 24, 2026
Left: This marks the third distinct legal workaround the administration has used to keep global tariffs in place after the Supreme Court struck down its emergency-powers tariffs in February, raising concerns about executive overreach and circumventing Congress.
Right: The United States has enforced its own century-old forced labor import ban rigorously, and it is reasonable to expect trading partners to meet the same basic human rights standard rather than gain a cost advantage by tolerating forced labor in supply chains.
- Federal Court Defies Supreme Court, Blocks Alabama GOP Map
May 27, 2026
Left: The federal court correctly identified intentional racial discrimination in Alabama's 2023 congressional map, which deliberately diluted Black voting power by spreading Black voters across districts to minimize their electoral influence
Right: The federal court panel is defying the Supreme Court's clear ruling in Louisiana v. Callais that race-based congressional districts violate the Constitution and the Voting Rights Act
- Democrats Consider Purging Virginia Supreme Court After Redistricting Loss
May 12, 2026
Left: Republicans across the country have systematically ignored court rulings and packed state courts when redistricting decisions don't favor them, establishing precedent for aggressive constitutional hardball
Right: Democrats are proposing to eliminate an entire state supreme court simply because it ruled against their unconstitutional attempt to gerrymander Virginia's congressional districts
- Supreme Court ruling unleashes new Republican redistricting wave
May 3, 2026
Left: The Supreme Court decision effectively guts the Voting Rights Act by allowing states to dilute minority voting power as long as they claim partisan motives, threatening decades of civil rights progress
Right: The Supreme Court correctly ruled that the Voting Rights Act cannot be used to force states into unconstitutional racial gerrymandering, preventing the sorting of Americans by race for political advantage
- Trump Asks Supreme Court, Third Time, to Restrict Mail Ballots
Sep 7, 2026
Left: A federal judge found the USPS rule likely unlawful and unconstitutional, citing the risk of disenfranchising millions of voters given how close implementation would be to the election.
Right: The administration frames the rule as a modest, lawful exercise of the Postal Service's authority to regulate mail handling, not an attempt to control elections themselves.
- Trump Admin Fights to Let USPS Block Some Mail Ballots
Sep 4, 2026
Left: A lower court found the rule likely usurps states' constitutional authority over election administration, which would require congressional approval rather than a Postal Service regulation.
Right: The rule only sets envelope-design and addressee-information standards for ballots sent through the mail, which the Postal Service has explicit congressional authority to regulate.
- Supreme Court Finalizes $5M Verdict Against Trump in Carroll Case
Aug 18, 2026
Left: The unanimous jury verdict and repeated Supreme Court rejections confirm that Trump was found liable for sexual abuse and defamation, and that finding is now permanently beyond legal challenge.
Right: Trump's legal team maintains he did nothing wrong and continues to view the litigation as a politically motivated attack, calling it a 'Democrat-funded travesty.'
- Supreme Court Allows Alabama Map Eliminating Black-Majority District
Jun 4, 2026
Left: The Court's conservative majority has effectively eliminated the Voting Rights Act's protections, allowing states to discriminate against minority voters without consequences
Right: The Supreme Court correctly applied its recent Louisiana v. Callais precedent that prohibits race-based redistricting except in cases of compelling state interest
- Supreme Court Guts Voting Rights Act in 6-3 Decision
May 8, 2026
Left: The decision effectively ends federal protection against racial gerrymandering and vote dilution, allowing Southern states to eliminate majority-minority districts that ensure Black and Latino representation in Congress
Right: The Court corrected Louisiana's unconstitutional redistricting map that relied too heavily on race, ensuring that electoral districts are drawn based on legitimate factors rather than racial considerations
- Supreme Court to decide who gets American citizenship at birth
Mar 30, 2026
Left: The 14th Amendment's plain language guarantees citizenship to all persons born in the United States, a principle upheld by the Supreme Court for 127 years and codified by Congress in 1940
Right: The 14th Amendment's phrase 'subject to the jurisdiction thereof' was intended for freed slaves, not children of temporary visitors or illegal immigrants who lack allegiance to the United States
- GOP Election Officials Join Democrats Against Trump's Mail Ballot Rule
Sep 12, 2026
Left: A federal district court and a unanimous three-judge appeals panel both found the executive order likely unlawful, reinforcing that this is not merely a partisan dispute but a legal one grounded in the president lacking authority to regulate state election procedures.
Right: The Trump administration views the mail ballot rule as a reasonable safeguard to standardize envelope design and verify voter lists, aiming to strengthen confidence in election integrity ahead of high-stakes midterms.
- Supreme Court Blocks Trump-Backed Missouri Map, Ending GOP's House Gambit
Sep 10, 2026
Left: The ruling upholds the Missouri Supreme Court's unanimous finding that the new map was never legally in effect and that voters have a constitutional right to weigh in via referendum before new districts take hold.
Right: The decision creates real confusion and unfairness for voters who already cast primary ballots in August under the new map, only to have the rules changed before the general election.
- Roberts Lets Trump's $600M Ballroom Construction Continue For Now
Aug 24, 2026
Left: Trump unilaterally demolished the historic East Wing and began major construction without seeking congressional approval, which two lower courts found exceeded his legal authority over federal property.
Right: The president has long-recognized authority to maintain, alter, and improve the White House complex, and courts should be wary of a single district judge deciding what security measures are 'strictly necessary' to protect the president and his family.
- Supreme Court Allows Alabama Map That Eliminates Black-Majority District
Jun 3, 2026
Left: The decision allows Alabama to intentionally discriminate against Black voters despite lower courts repeatedly finding the map violates constitutional protections
Right: The Court correctly ended judicial activism by preventing unelected federal judges from imposing their preferred electoral maps on Alabama
- Virginia Democrats Consider Packing State Supreme Court After Redistricting Loss
May 13, 2026
Left: Republicans have systematically gerrymandered congressional maps nationwide to maintain power despite losing the popular vote, making Democratic countermeasures necessary for fair representation
Right: Democrats attempted an unconstitutional power grab that would have given them 10 of 11 congressional seats despite Virginia being a competitive purple state
- Supreme Court Clears Alabama to Eliminate Majority-Black Congressional District
May 12, 2026
Left: The decision undermines voting rights protections and will dilute Black political representation in Alabama, reducing majority-Black districts from two to one
Right: The decision corrects unconstitutional racial gerrymandering by preventing districts drawn primarily based on race rather than traditional redistricting principles
- Liberal Judges Expand Wisconsin Supreme Court Majority Until 2030
Apr 8, 2026
Left: Taylor's victory represents the fourth consecutive win for liberal candidates, demonstrating sustained voter support for progressive judicial values in Wisconsin
Right: Conservative judicial philosophy suffered another setback as liberal activists continue to politicize Wisconsin's supposedly nonpartisan Supreme Court
- Trump Asks Supreme Court to Restart Deportations to Dangerous Third Countries
Sep 25, 2026
Left: Migrants have been deported to countries like the Central African Republic and South Sudan, places the U.S. government itself classifies as extreme-risk due to armed conflict and terrorism, without meaningful notice or a chance to contest the destination.
Right: The administration argues third-country removals are a legal and essential tool for removing individuals, including those with criminal convictions, when their home countries refuse to accept them back.
- Appeals Court Revives GOP Map SCOTUS Already Blocked Twice
Sep 22, 2026
Left: The Supreme Court has already twice blocked this Republican-drawn map, and a panel of three Republican-appointed judges overriding that signal raises concerns about judicial independence and partisan alignment on the bench.
Right: Missouri already conducted its August primary using the 2025 map, so reverting to the 2022 lines for the general election would force some voters to choose among candidates they never had a chance to select in a primary, raising a genuine constitutional concern under Article I, Section 2.
- Supreme Court Blocks Trump-Backed Missouri Map After Primaries Already Held
Sep 13, 2026
Left: The reversal restores districts drawn through an ordinary post-census process rather than a map that Republican lawmakers redrew under pressure from Trump specifically to manufacture an extra GOP seat.
Right: Voters already cast primary ballots under the 2025 map, and forcing a switch to different districts for the general election disenfranchises people who campaigned, donated, and voted based on those boundaries.
- Tennessee GOP Eliminates Last Democratic District, Forces Cohen Retirement
May 15, 2026
Left: The redistricting deliberately silences Black voters in Memphis by splitting their community into three separate districts to dilute their political power
Right: The redistricting follows proper legal procedures after the Supreme Court ruled that race-based congressional districts violate constitutional principles
- Supreme Court Asked to Restore Mail-Order Abortion Pill Access
May 3, 2026
Left: The 5th Circuit ruling creates immediate chaos for patients and healthcare providers nationwide by disrupting established medical protocols that have been safely used for years
Right: The FDA's mail-order policy allows out-of-state providers to circumvent state abortion laws and undermine the will of voters in states that have chosen to restrict abortion
- Alito Hints at Retirement, Says Overturning Roe Took 'Courage'
Oct 3, 2026
Left: Dobbs eliminated a constitutional right that had protected women's reproductive autonomy for nearly 50 years, and framing its reversal as requiring 'courage' obscures the real-world harm it caused to people seeking abortion care.
Right: Alito's account highlights the genuine personal and professional sacrifices justices make when ruling on contested issues, including lost friendships and ongoing security threats.
- Supreme Court to Decide if ICE Can Detain Immigrants Indefinitely, No Bond
Oct 2, 2026
Left: Due process protections should apply to immigrants who have lived in the U.S. for years, even those without legal status, since a bond hearing simply allows a judge to assess flight risk and danger rather than guaranteeing release.
Right: The administration argues federal law plainly states that noncitizens who are not 'clearly and beyond a doubt' entitled to admission 'shall be detained,' and this provision should apply regardless of how long ago someone entered the country illegally.
- Alito Reverses Course, Recuses From Major Oil Climate Case
Sep 29, 2026
Left: The recusal validates months of advocacy from environmental and judicial watchdog groups who argued Alito's oil and gas holdings created a conflict of interest under the court's own ethics code.
Right: Alito does not own stock in either Suncor Energy or ExxonMobil, the actual parties to the case, and his recusal came without any stated explanation or admission of wrongdoing.
- Kavanaugh Blocks Trump-Backed Missouri Map, Reverting to 6-2 Districts
Sep 9, 2026
Left: The Missouri Supreme Court unanimously found that a citizen-backed referendum petition legally suspended the new map before it could take effect, meaning the state's highest court simply enforced its own constitution.
Right: Missouri Republicans argue the state faces an unprecedented and chaotic situation, having already run its August primary under the new map only to be forced to use different districts for the general election.
- Trump Tells Supreme Court: Judge Can't Halt White House Ballroom
Aug 15, 2026
Left: A federal district court and a divided appeals court both concluded that Trump lacks unilateral authority to demolish and rebuild the East Wing without congressional approval, reflecting long-standing checks on executive power over federal property.
Right: The president has historically been granted authority to renovate and secure the White House, and this project should be treated no differently than past presidential renovations.
- Supreme Court weakens Native American voting rights enforcement
May 19, 2026
Left: Private lawsuits by advocacy groups and voters have been the primary enforcement mechanism for Section 2 of the Voting Rights Act, bringing most cases that protect minority voting rights
Right: The Supreme Court appropriately sent cases back for reconsideration in light of its recent Louisiana v. Callais ruling that limited race-based gerrymandering
- Supreme Court Guts Voting Rights Act, Enables Racial Gerrymandering
May 6, 2026
Left: The decision completes Chief Justice John Roberts's decades-long project to dismantle the Voting Rights Act, which he began as a young Reagan Justice Department aide in the 1980s
Right: The Court correctly determined that federal courts lack constitutional authority to police partisan gerrymandering, which is a political question best resolved through the democratic process
- Supreme Court Guts Voting Rights Act, Sparking Redistricting Wars
May 3, 2026
Left: The ruling effectively eliminates the Voting Rights Act's ability to protect minority representation, allowing states to dilute Black and Hispanic voting power as long as they claim partisan motivations
Right: The Court correctly ruled that the Voting Rights Act protects ballot access, not politicians' ability to sort Americans by race for political advantage
- Supreme Court Unanimously Backs Pro-Life Centers Against State Investigation
Apr 29, 2026
Left: The ruling allows anti-abortion centers to avoid accountability for potentially deceptive practices that mislead women seeking reproductive healthcare
Right: The unanimous decision protects First Amendment rights of religious organizations from government harassment and intimidation campaigns
- Supreme Court Blocks Trump's Mail Ballot Rules 7-2
Sep 15, 2026
Left: The Postal Service rule would have imposed unprecedented federal control over how states run mail-in voting, an area historically left to state discretion.
Right: The rule was framed by the administration as an election-security measure meant to verify that ballots go only to confirmed registered voters.
- House Vote to Cap Supreme Court at Nine Justices Fails Along Party Lines
Sep 4, 2026
Left: The Constitution leaves the size of the Supreme Court to Congress, a power lawmakers have exercised multiple times since 1789, and permanently locking it at nine would strip future Congresses of that legitimate authority.
Right: A fixed, nine-justice Court prevents whichever party controls Congress from expanding the bench simply to overpower rulings it dislikes, protecting the Court's independence for both parties long-term.
- Missouri Court Blocks Trump-Backed Map Days Before Ballot Deadline
Sep 4, 2026
Left: More than 305,000 Missourians signed a petition to have a say over congressional lines drawn specifically to eliminate a Democratic seat, and the court affirmed their constitutional right to a referendum.
Right: The state legislature and governor followed proper legislative process to redraw districts, an authority the same court had already ruled constitutional earlier this year.
- Democrats split: Impeach Trump again, or focus on affordability?
Sep 1, 2026
Left: Jeffries and party leaders want to keep the midterm message centered on lowering costs for housing, health care and energy, believing affordability is the winning issue with swing voters.
Right: Democrats are using inflammatory rhetoric, such as comparing the Supreme Court's conservative majority to the pro-slavery Dred Scott decision, to justify radical structural changes to the judiciary.