Topics /
Judiciary
51 stories on Judiciary. For each one: what the left says, what the right says, and what both agree on. RSS feed
- Judge Probes if Trump Lawyers Misled Court on Golf Course
Nov 2, 2026
Left: The administration cut down more than 400 trees at a historic public golf course by giving notice late on a Friday before a holiday weekend, suggesting an attempt to minimize scrutiny and public response.
Right: Disputes over internal agency communication and bureaucratic timing on a parks and recreation matter are being escalated into claims of ethical misconduct, which may be an overreach for what could be miscommunication rather than deliberate deception.
- Poland's Court Takeover: 'Restoring Rule of Law' or 'Coup d'État'?
Nov 2, 2026
Left: The Constitutional Tribunal was stacked with judges appointed improperly by the previous Law and Justice government, undermining its legitimacy as an impartial constitutional check.
Right: The Constitutional Tribunal has served as a check on EU overreach, including defending Poland's sovereign currency and border control policies against Brussels-driven mandates.
- Poland's Top Court Takeover: Judicial Reform or Coup d'État?
Nov 1, 2026
Left: The Constitutional Tribunal has been packed with judges loyal to the former Law and Justice (PiS) government, undermining its legitimacy as a neutral arbiter of Polish law.
Right: Tusk's government is circumventing established constitutional procedure by having the Sejm speaker swear in judges rather than going through the president, as the law requires.
- Court Rejects Trump Bid to Set Aside 20,000 CA Ballots
Nov 1, 2026
Left: The DOJ's list of suspected noncitizens was found not credible by both the district court and appeals court majority, undermining the basis for the entire legal action.
Right: Federal law clearly prohibits noncitizens from voting, and the DOJ views enforcing that law as a basic governmental duty rather than a political agenda.
- Trump-Appointed Judge Blocks Trump's Ban on CNN, MSNBC, Politico
Sep 24, 2026
Left: The ruling confirms that press access to the White House cannot be revoked as retaliation for critical or unfavorable coverage without violating due process protections.
Right: The administration argues it has compelling authority to enforce minimum professionalism standards for journalists granted privileged access to the White House complex.
- Court Blocks Trump's White House Ballroom; He Vows Supreme Court Fight
Aug 9, 2026
Left: The D.C. Circuit's 2-1 ruling affirms that the president cannot unilaterally demolish part of the White House and construct a $400 million complex without congressional authorization, reinforcing constitutional checks on executive power.
Right: Trump argues that as an elected president, he has inherent authority to renovate, secure, and improve the White House without needing permission from Congress, as past presidents have done for over two centuries.
- Brazilian Court Justice, Lula's Ex-Lawyer, Extended Voting at His Request
Oct 27, 2026
Left: Lula's win reflects a legitimate democratic comeback after trailing in the first round, the first such reversal in decades, demonstrating the resilience of Brazilian voters' preferences.
Right: A sitting Supreme Court justice who personally served as Lula's defense lawyer in his corruption case unilaterally extended voting nationwide at the request of his former client's campaign, a conflict of interest that undermines judicial impartiality.
- Trump-Appointed Judge Rules Trump's Press Ban Unconstitutional
Sep 24, 2026
Left: The ruling reinforces that press credentials cannot be stripped based on the content or tone of a news outlet's coverage without violating due process rights guaranteed by the Constitution.
Right: The fact that a Trump-appointed judge issued this ruling demonstrates that the judiciary is functioning independently, and the administration can pursue appeal rather than claiming bias.
- Trump Asks Supreme Court to Restart Deportations to Dangerous Third Countries
Sep 25, 2026
Left: Migrants have been deported to countries like the Central African Republic and South Sudan, places the U.S. government itself classifies as extreme-risk due to armed conflict and terrorism, without meaningful notice or a chance to contest the destination.
Right: The administration argues third-country removals are a legal and essential tool for removing individuals, including those with criminal convictions, when their home countries refuse to accept them back.
- Judge Accuses Trump Officials of Deceiving Court Over Tree Removal
Oct 14, 2026
Left: The administration cut down 430 to 529 mature trees at a 106-year-old public golf course with only hours of notice, filing paperwork just before a holiday weekend to minimize scrutiny and public backlash.
Right: The restoration and tree removal plan traces back to a 2019 National Park Service report, predating Trump's redevelopment proposal, so this reflects pre-existing agency planning rather than an improper end-run around the court.
- Judge Again Blocks Trump's Name on Kennedy Center as Board Shuts It Down
Sep 15, 2026
Left: Judge Cooper's ruling reinforces that a congressionally chartered living memorial to JFK cannot be unilaterally rebranded by a board stacked with the president's own political appointees.
Right: The board, now led by Trump allies, argues the center faces genuine structural danger and near-term bankruptcy, with part of the ceiling having already collapsed, making swift action urgent.
- Judge Blocks Trump Mail Ballot Rule Again, Days Before Ballots Mail Out
Aug 28, 2026
Left: States and voting rights groups warn that the USPS rule was rushed into effect with no time for election officials to redesign ballots, reorder envelopes, retrain staff, or upload voter data before ballots must go out.
Right: The executive order is framed as a straightforward measure to verify citizenship and protect election integrity by ensuring only eligible voters receive and cast mail ballots.
- Judge Blocks Trump's Cost-Saving Move to Keep FBI in DC
Aug 19, 2026
Left: Congress explicitly directed the General Services Administration in 2022 and 2023 to choose a new FBI headquarters from three sites in Maryland and Virginia, and the administration bypassed that legal process to keep the bureau in Washington.
Right: The Trump administration and FBI Director Kash Patel argued that relocating to the already-existing Reagan Building would save taxpayers billions of dollars compared to building a new facility from scratch in Greenbelt.
- Judge Voids Trump's Firing of Comey's Daughter as Prosecutor
Oct 27, 2026
Left: The ruling confirms long-standing civil service protections exist precisely to prevent career prosecutors from being purged for political reasons, and the court found Comey was targeted because of her father's prominence as a Trump critic.
Right: The administration argues that assistant U.S. attorneys wield significant delegated executive authority and should be removable at the discretion of the president or attorney general, consistent with Article II power over law enforcement.
- Judge Again Blocks Trump's Mail Ballot Rules as Voting Begins
Sep 5, 2026
Left: States are legally required to mail millions of ballots on fixed timelines and cannot suddenly overhaul their systems this close to an election, making disenfranchisement of eligible voters nearly certain if the rule took effect now.
Right: The executive order and USPS rule aim to modernize ballot tracking with unique barcodes and state-submitted voter lists to reduce the risk of fraudulent or misdirected mail ballots.
- Judge Lets Texas Stall Extraditing ICE Officer Accused of Shooting Migrant
Aug 27, 2026
Left: Minnesota officials fear Castro poses a genuine flight risk, pointing to recorded jail calls where he discussed marrying a woman in Mexico and buying a house there upon release.
Right: Governor Abbott has explicit statutory authority under Texas law to investigate whether Castro legally qualifies as a 'fugitive' before signing any extradition warrant, and he has not refused the request outright.
- Bolsonaro's Son Flees Brazil as Courts Seize Passport Amid Election Dispute
Oct 29, 2026
Left: The passport order came from an independent Supreme Court justice acting within an ongoing criminal investigation into money laundering and financial irregularities, not from Lula or his political allies.
Right: The extension of poll closing hours by a justice who previously served as Lula's personal attorney, specifically in a pro-Lula region, raises legitimate questions about the fairness of the vote count that deserve scrutiny rather than dismissal.
- Trump-Appointed Judge Rules Against Trump's Media Ban
Oct 14, 2026
Left: The ruling confirms that revoking press credentials without advance notice violates journalists' due process rights, since the White House only sent explanatory letters after the ban was already imposed.
Right: The president has legitimate authority to manage access to the White House complex, including security-related judgments about who receives hard-pass credentials.
- Judge Blocks Trump's Big Bend Border Wall as 'Historic Victory'
Oct 3, 2026
Left: The ruling protects a 'crown-jewel' national park and fragile desert ecosystem from irreversible damage like cleared vegetation, cut roads, and permanent floodlighting that no amount of money could later restore
Right: The ruling is a temporary, not final, setback and the administration maintains construction is a necessary part of a broader $46 billion strategy to secure the entire southern border
- Supreme Court allows execution after botched lethal injection claims
Oct 1, 2026
Left: Pike's jury never heard evidence of her childhood sexual abuse and rape, information her attorneys argue was critical mitigating context that could have led to a lesser sentence.
Right: Pike was convicted by a jury of a brutal, premeditated murder that included torturing her victim for roughly 30 minutes, carving a pentagram into her body, and keeping a piece of her skull as a trophy.
- Soros-Backed Philly DA Referred to DOJ Over Murder Case
Sep 16, 2026
Left: The judge's referral involves serious but unproven allegations, and neither Krasner nor Stiegler has been charged with any crime.
Right: A federal judge concluded there is evidence Krasner and his deputy pressured prosecutors to present a false narrative to the court, which the judge said could amount to criminal conspiracy.
- Judge Again Blocks Trump's Bid to Limit Birthright Citizenship
Sep 4, 2026
Left: The Supreme Court's June ruling in Trump v. Barbara already settled that children born in the U.S. to undocumented immigrants and temporary visitors are citizens at birth, making Trump's new order an attempt to defy binding precedent.
Right: The administration argues its narrower August order targets specific, limited categories the Supreme Court's ruling didn't explicitly address, such as children of alien enemies, foreign terrorist organization members, and diplomatic staff, rather than relitigating the broader birthright citizenship question.
- Judge Questions DOJ Claim: Adding Trump's Name Isn't 'Renaming' Kennedy Center
Aug 28, 2026
Left: The board's plan to inscribe Trump's name on the facade and rename surrounding grounds 'President Donald J. Trump Plaza' looks like a workaround designed to defy a federal judge's earlier ruling that blocked such a renaming.
Right: The inscription is intended to recognize Trump's personal role in leading fundraising and renovation efforts at the Kennedy Center, not to change its official legal name.
- Judge Lifts Block on Trump Mail Ballot Order Before Midterms
Aug 26, 2026
Left: The ruling is procedural, not a verdict on the legality of Trump's mail-in ballot restrictions, and the Supreme Court explicitly left open whether the underlying policy is lawful.
Right: The Supreme Court's 6-3 decision cleared the way by finding the legal challenges premature, since courts should review final rules rather than block anticipated ones.
- Utah Supreme Court Justice Resigns Amid Affair Allegations With Redistricting Attorney
May 9, 2026
Left: The resignation protects judicial independence by removing a justice whose impartiality had been compromised by personal relationships with case attorneys
Right: The justice's relationship with an attorney arguing redistricting cases created an obvious conflict of interest that compromised judicial integrity
- Judge Halts Mamdani's 'Tax the Rich' Rollout Over Due Process
Sep 30, 2026
Left: The pied-à-terre tax targets a narrow slice of very wealthy property owners with second homes worth $5 million or more, part of a broader effort to make the ultra-rich pay more toward city services.
Right: The rollout demonstrates governmental overreach and incompetence, with the city mailing tax notices to thousands of homeowners without first verifying whether the properties were actually second homes or primary residences.
- Judge Skeptical Trump's 'Anti-Weaponization Fund' Is Truly Dead
Sep 20, 2026
Left: The fund's demise on paper doesn't erase the underlying goal of using taxpayer money to compensate Trump allies, including Jan. 6 rioters and anti-abortion activists convicted under the FACE Act, since the DOJ's ordinary Judgment Fund could serve the same purpose with far less transparency or oversight.
Right: Attorney General Todd Blanche formally rescinded the Anti-Weaponization Fund in August and has repeatedly affirmed under oath, including at his confirmation hearing, that it is dead, which should be sufficient to render the lawsuit moot.
- Judge Blocks Trump's Mail Ballot Rule Again, Defying SCOTUS?
Aug 29, 2026
Left: The USPS rule imposes onerous new compliance burdens on states just months before the 2026 midterms, making it practically impossible for election officials to meet the requirements in time.
Right: The USPS rule simply asks states to submit basic voter data, such as names, addresses, and unique barcodes, to help secure the mail ballot process, far short of stricter measures like proof-of-citizenship requirements.
- Judge Blocks Maryland Democrats' Redistricting Ballot Measure
Aug 27, 2026
Left: The amendment was a direct response to a Republican-led national redistricting push, backed by President Trump, that is expected to net the GOP roughly a dozen House seats before the midterms.
Right: The ruling vindicates concerns that Democratic lawmakers rushed the constitutional amendment through a hastily called special session without following the state's own legal procedures for proposing ballot referenda.
- Judge Calls Trump Visa Ban on 75 Nations Illegal, 'Orwellian'
Aug 24, 2026
Left: The policy blocked immigrant visas for applicants from 75 countries even after consular officers individually reviewed and approved them, making the outcome 'predetermined' regardless of merit.
Right: The State Department designed the policy to protect taxpayer-funded public benefits by screening out immigrants deemed likely to become financially dependent on the government.
- Judge Cites Trans Identity, Trump Pardons in Lenient Sentence for Bessent Plotter
Aug 19, 2026
Left: Riley English was in the grips of a severe mental health crisis and substance abuse at the time of the plot, and her defense attorney described her as terrified and traumatized by fears about how the second Trump administration would treat transgender people.
Right: A person plotted to assassinate a sitting Cabinet member, brought a knife and homemade firebombs to the Capitol, and initially considered targeting the House speaker and the defense secretary before switching targets, yet received a sentence far below the 10-year request and even below sentencing guidelines.
- DOJ Fights to Revive Charges Against Wrongly Deported 'Maryland Man'
Aug 18, 2026
Left: Judge Crenshaw found 'presumptive vindictiveness,' concluding Abrego García would never have faced these charges had he not successfully sued the government over his wrongful 2025 deportation to a notorious El Salvador prison.
Right: Career prosecutors, not political appointees, made the decision to indict based on evidence they believe proves beyond a reasonable doubt that Abrego García committed human smuggling.
- Judge Halts Mamdani's Second-Home Tax After Homeowner Data Exposed
Aug 11, 2026
Left: The tax is intended to raise roughly $500 million annually from owners of multimillion-dollar second homes to help fund city services amid a broader affordability crisis.
Right: The rollout exposed private information on nearly a million homeowners through a publicly searchable database, raising serious privacy and safety concerns even for people who don't owe the tax.
- Court Blocks Trump's Mail-In Voting Rules for Midterms
Jul 27, 2026
Left: The Constitution assigns states, not the federal government, the authority to administer elections, and this order represents executive overreach into that domain.
Right: The executive order was designed to safeguard elections by verifying voter eligibility and preventing noncitizens from casting ballots, a goal the administration considers a legitimate federal interest.
- Court Blocks Trump Mail-Ballot Rules; Fight Heads to Supreme Court
Jul 26, 2026
Left: The executive order rests on the false premise that the 2020 election was marred by widespread fraud, a claim courts and election officials have repeatedly rejected.
Right: The executive order simply seeks to tighten mail-in voting integrity, including verifying citizenship and standardizing ballot handling, to prevent fraud and restore public confidence in elections.
- DOJ Invokes Dormant 1996 'Terrorist Court' for First-Ever Deportation
Jul 20, 2026
Left: The court allows the government to use classified evidence, including material obtained without following normal evidentiary rules, raising due process concerns for someone who may never see the full case against them.
Right: Congress built this court with bipartisan support specifically to handle dangerous terrorism cases requiring classified evidence, and using it now finally fulfills its intended purpose after 30 years of disuse by both parties.
- Judge Blocks Trump Bid to Set Aside 20,000 CA Ballots
Oct 29, 2026
Left: States have constitutional authority over their own election administration, and last-minute federal intervention threatens that sovereignty just as voting is already underway.
Right: Federal law prohibits noncitizens from voting, and the Justice Department is simply seeking to ensure states comply with that law before ballots are counted.
- Federal Appeals Court Skeptical of DOJ Bid to Toss California Ballots
Oct 27, 2026
Left: The Elections Clause gives state legislatures, not the federal executive, authority over election administration, and California followed its own legally adopted procedures.
Right: The Justice Department believes it has identified roughly 20,000 mail ballots tied to individuals it suspects are noncitizens and argues these ballots should be verified before being counted alongside legitimate votes.
- Judge Permanently Blocks Trump From Reviving Dismissed Vandalism Case
Oct 2, 2026
Left: The government itself admitted Hearn committed no crime, with Interior Department and National Park Service reports confirming the pool damage was caused by a botched contractor installation, not vandalism.
Right: The Reflecting Pool renovation was a priority project for President Trump ahead of the nation's 250th birthday, and the visible damage to the newly installed lining was a legitimate public concern worth investigating.
- Judge Rules Trump Can't Sue Pollster Over Bad Poll
Sep 25, 2026
Left: The ruling reinforces that political speech, including flawed or inaccurate polling, receives the highest level of First Amendment protection and cannot be repackaged as consumer fraud.
Right: The Des Moines Register poll was a dramatic outlier showing Harris ahead in Iowa just days before Trump won the state by 13 points, a 16-point miss that fueled national headlines favorable to Harris.
- Protesters Form Human Chain to Stop Trump Demolishing Kennedy Center
Sep 20, 2026
Left: Trump's takeover of the Kennedy Center board, removal of prior leadership, and attempt to place his name on the building represent an unprecedented politicization of a nonpartisan cultural institution meant to honor JFK.
Right: The Kennedy Center was closed for legitimate safety reasons after a piece of its ceiling collapsed, making renovation a practical necessity rather than a political stunt.
- DOJ Says 'Vindictive Prosecution' Ruling Against Abrego Garcia Was Wrong
Aug 25, 2026
Left: A federal judge found the government failed to rebut a presumption of vindictiveness, noting DHS knew of the 2022 traffic stop for over two years before suddenly reopening the case only after Abrego Garcia won his wrongful-deportation lawsuit.
Right: Career prosecutors reviewed the evidence and concluded beyond a reasonable doubt that Abrego Garcia committed human smuggling, and that determination should not be overturned based on suspicions about timing alone.
- Trump-packed commission approves White House ballroom despite court order
Apr 2, 2026
Left: The commission is compromised by conflicts of interest, with Trump appointees including chair Will Scharf who also serves as Trump's staff secretary voting on their boss's pet project
Right: The commission followed proper procedures including an extensive public comment period where everyone who wanted to speak was heard before making their decision
- Judge Reinstates US Attorney Trump Fired Within the Hour
Oct 3, 2026
Left: The ruling reinforces that federal law gives district judges, not the president, authority to fill U.S. attorney vacancies when the Senate confirmation process stalls, and the statute includes no provision allowing a president to simply fire that judicially-appointed official and reassert control.
Right: The president should retain broad authority over who serves in politically sensitive law enforcement positions like U.S. attorney, since these officials wield significant prosecutorial power on his behalf.
- Biden Judge Rules Congress Can't Ban Noncitizens From Voting
Oct 3, 2026
Left: The ruling rests on a textual reading of the Constitution, which assigns states — not Congress — the primary authority to set voter qualifications for elections.
Right: Congress has long relied on its immigration and federal election authority to bar noncitizens from voting, and this ruling undermines a commonsense safeguard that has existed since 1996.
- Judge: Pentagon Can Fire Journalists Over CBS Interview
Sep 7, 2026
Left: The firings followed the journalists' reporting on a real mental health crisis aboard the USS Abraham Lincoln, including sailors attempting to jump overboard after a grueling 250-plus-day deployment tied to the Iran war.
Right: The judge, applying established public-employee speech law, found that Slavin and Korte gave a pre-approved interview as part of their official job duties, not as private citizens, so their firing does not violate the First Amendment.
- Judge rejects Trump's third bid to erase felony conviction
Aug 30, 2026
Left: Judge Hellerstein's 35-page ruling directly rejects the idea that covering up an affair falls within a president's official duties, reinforcing that immunity has limits.
Right: Trump's legal team maintains that the Supreme Court's immunity ruling, along with constitutional protections, should have compelled removal of the case to federal court and its dismissal.
- Supreme Court Lets Trump's Ballroom Demolition Proceed—For Now
Aug 24, 2026
Left: Trump promised the ballroom would be privately funded and wouldn't touch the existing structure, yet the East Wing was fully demolished and taxpayers are now covering roughly half of a project that has ballooned from $200 million to $600 million.
Right: The Supreme Court's stay recognizes that a single district judge should not have final say over what security measures are 'strictly necessary' to protect the president, his family, and visiting foreign dignitaries.
- Court Ducks Ruling on Trump's Wartime Deportation Law by Declaring Case Moot
Aug 15, 2026
Left: The administration deported the three named plaintiffs before the court could rule, effectively using removal as a tactic to evade judicial review of the Alien Enemies Act's legality.
Right: The court found it had no jurisdiction to rule because the named plaintiffs were no longer in the country and had been removed through legitimate, separate legal channels under the Immigration and Nationality Act.
- Court Limits, But Preserves, Trump's Third-Country Deportations
Sep 20, 2026
Left: Migrants deported under this policy were sent to countries like the Central African Republic, Ghana, Liberia, and Sierra Leone with little or no warning, sometimes learning their destination only hours into the flight.
Right: The court's ruling still allows third-country deportations to continue, preserving a tool the administration considers essential when migrants' home countries refuse to accept them back.